Haonan Zhang

Research

Job Market Paper

How Does Online Shopping Affect Offline Price Sensitivity?   with Shirsho Biswas and Hema Yoganarasimhan

-- Under Review at Marketing Science
📖 Abstract The rapid growth of e-commerce has significantly transformed consumer behavior, raising questions about how the adoption of online shopping influences offline shopping. This paper investigates whether consumers who adopt online shopping with a retailer become more price sensitive in their subsequent offline purchases with the same retailer. Using transaction-level data from a large Brazilian pet supplies retailer operating both online and offline channels, we compare “adopters” – customers who began shopping online after a period of offline-only purchasing – with “non-adopters” who remained offline-only. We estimate a discrete choice logit model with individual-level heterogeneity, using a novel algorithm to handle high-dimensional fixed effects and address price endogeneity. We apply a staggered difference-in-differences approach to estimate the Average Treatment Effect on the Treated (ATT). We find that offline price sensitivity increases significantly post-online adoption in three of four product categories, particularly in low-switching-cost items like pet hygiene. Counterfactual pricing simulations show that incorporating these behavioral spillovers into pricing strategies can increase firm profits by up to 4.1%. These results underscore the importance of recognizing cross-channel effects in consumer behavior and contribute to the literature on pricing and multichannel retailing by identifying online adoption as a key driver of offline price sensitivity.

Working Papers

Channel Choice and Customer Value   with Shirsho Biswas and Hema Yoganarasimhan

-- Under Second Round Review at Journal of Marketing
📖 Abstract The rapid growth of digital shopping channels has prompted many traditional retailers to invest in e-commerce websites and mobile apps. While prior literature shows that multichannel customers tend to be more valuable, it overlooks how the reason for adopting a new channel may shape post-adoption behavior. Using transactionlevel data from a major Brazilian pet supplies retailer, we examine how adoption of online shopping—by previously offline-only customers—affects post-adoption spend, profitability, and channel usage. We study four distinct adoption pathways: organic adoption, adoption due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Black Friday promotions, and a newly launched loyalty program. We find that although all adopter groups increase their spending relative to offline-only customers, post-adoption behavior differs based on the reason for adoption. COVID-19 adopters behave similarly to organic adopters in terms of spending, but show greater offline stickiness consistent with consumer inertia and habit theory, yielding higher profits due to higher offline margins. In contrast, promotion-driven adopters spend less post-adoption due to forward buying and exhibit lower profitability. Our findings caution against treating all multichannel customers as equal and highlight the importance of incorporating behavioral theories into forecasting and targeting strategies. Firms should account for adoption motives when evaluating channel and promotional investments.

Content and Pricing Strategies for Digital Video Games   with Scott Shriver and Hema Yoganarasimhan

-- Working Paper
📖 Abstract The video game industry has experienced a wave of disruption as consumers rapidly shift to acquiring and consuming content through digital channels. Incumbent game publishers have struggled to adapt their content and pricing strategies to shifting consumption patterns and increased competition from low-cost independent suppliers. Recently, game publishers have pursued new business models that feature downloadable content (DLC) services offered in conjunction with or as a replacement for traditional physical media. While service-based models can potentially extract additional surplus from the market by allowing for more customized content bundles and pricing than with physically distributed media, exploiting these opportunities poses a challenge to firms who must attempt to optimize their offerings over a formidably complex decision space. In this paper, we develop a structural framework to facilitate the recovery of consumer preferences for game content and the optimization of firm content/price strategies. Our approach is to leverage rich covariation in observed content consumption and DLC service subscriptions to infer consumer content valuations and price sensitivities. We devise a joint model of video game activity and demand for downloadable content, where consumers sequentially make (discrete) DLC subscription choices followed by (continuous) choices of how much to play. Our model accounts for forward-looking consumer expectations about declining content prices and attendant concerns for dynamic selection bias in our demand estimates. We document evidence of heterogeneous preferences for content and significant effects of DLC availability on game usage. Our counterfactual experiments suggest that compressing the DLC release cycle and moving to a recurring fee structure are both viable ways to increase revenues.

The Hidden Costs of Flexibility: JIT Scheduling and Turnover in a U.S. Restaurant Chain   with Qiuping Yu

-- Working Paper
📖 Abstract Just-in-time (JIT) scheduling, increasingly augmented by algorithmic tools, allows service firms to dynamically match labor supply with demand. While effective in reducing labor costs, such systems often generate precarious schedules—particularly in retail and service sectors—raising concerns about employee well-being and long-run firm performance. Using granular shift-level data covering over 2.3 million hours worked by 2,400+ frontline employees over three years at a national casual dining chain, we examine how scheduling quality – along three dimensions: predictability (advance notice), consistency (temporal stability), and sufficiency (adequacy of hours) – affects worker turnover. Leveraging a Cox proportional hazards model with an instrumental variables approach, we find that: (1) a 10 p.p. increase in real-time shift additions (with no advance notice) raises turnover risk by 7.1%, while additions with short (two-day) notice have no significant effect; (2) variability in shift timing increases attrition, but volatility in weekly hours does not; and (3) each additional weekly hour worked reduces turnover risk by 2.3%. These results highlight the hidden costs of just-in-time scheduling that prioritizes flexibility over schedule quality. Our findings offer actionable insights for firms seeking to improve workforce stability and contribute empirical evidence to ongoing policy debates on fair scheduling practices.